How to Choose a Base Game for Game Night
By TeeTurtle | Graphic t-shirts, reversible plushies, and more! | Published: 2026-10-19
Category: Buying Guides
Choosing the right base game for game night depends on player count, complexity, and theme. Our guide breaks down key factors and offers clear decision rules.
Quick Answer
To choose a base game for game night, match the game's player count, play time, and complexity to your group's size and experience. For most groups, a strategic card game like Here to Slay or Unstable Unicorns offers a good balance of fun and depth.
Understand Your Group's Size and Experience
Before picking a base game, consider how many people typically attend your game night. Some games support 2-6 players, while others are designed for 2-4 or 2-8. If your group often splits into smaller sessions, a game that works well with 2 players is a must.
Also think about the experience level of your players. Some base games are easy to learn and play quickly, making them ideal for casual groups. Others have more strategic depth, which might appeal to seasoned gamers but could overwhelm beginners.
Match Play Time to Your Evening
A base game that takes 30-60 minutes is a common sweet spot for game night. It's long enough to feel substantial but short enough to play multiple rounds or fit into a busy evening. If you have limited time, look for games with a shorter playtime, and if you have a dedicated game night, you might prefer longer, more immersive experiences.
Keep in mind that some games can run longer with more players. Check the listed play time and consider how your group's size might affect the actual duration.
Consider Theme and Humor
The theme of a base game can make or break your game night. Some groups love fantasy and role-playing themes, while others prefer humor or adult-oriented content. If your group enjoys lighthearted and slightly irreverent humor, a game like Unstable Unicorns NSFW might be a hit. If you prefer a family-friendly adventure, look for games with a more wholesome theme.
Always check the recommended age and content notes. Some games are explicitly for adults (21+) and may not be suitable for all groups.
Decision Rules for Choosing a Base Game
- Check player count: Count the typical number of players in your game night. Choose a game that supports that number comfortably. For example, if you often have 5 players, avoid games that only support up to 4. Always look at the maximum players listed on the box.
- Assess play time: Review the listed play time and decide if it fits your evening. If you want to play multiple rounds, pick a game under 60 minutes. For a longer, immersive session, you can go over 60 minutes. Consider how many games you want to play in one night.
- Match complexity to your group: Consider the experience level of your players. If your group is new to board games, choose a simpler game with straightforward rules. For experienced players, a more strategic game will be more engaging. When in doubt, start with a game that has clear, simple rules.
- Consider theme and content: Think about the humor and theme your group enjoys. Some games are family-friendly, while others are explicitly for adults. Always check the age rating and content notes before buying. Make sure the game's content is appropriate for all players.
Base Games to Consider
- Here to Slay: Base Game: Here to Slay is a strategic card game from the creators of Unstable Unicorns, for 2-6 players and 30-60 minutes of play. This game suits groups that enjoy strategic role-playing elements and want a flexible player count for different game night sizes.
Here to Slay: Base Game - Unstable Unicorns: Classic Edition: Base Game: Unstable Unicorns: Classic Edition is a strategic card game where the goal is to collect 7 Unicorns in your Stable, using magic and upgrades to hinder opponents. It's a great pick for groups that like tactical play and a bit of friendly sabotage, with a clear objective that's easy to grasp.
Unstable Unicorns: Classic Edition: Base Game - Command of Nature: Base Game: Command of Nature is a strategic tabletop game for 2 or 4 players, where you play as a Sage summoning warriors from four factions. This game is ideal for smaller groups or head-to-head play, offering a different strategic experience with its faction-based combat.
- Unstable Unicorns NSFW: Base Game: Unstable Unicorns NSFW is an adult version of Unstable Unicorns for 2-8 players, ages 21+, with 114 cards and the same strategic gameplay. If your group enjoys adult humor and larger player counts, this version keeps the fun going with up to 8 players.
Which Base Game Fits Your Group?
Best for
- Groups that love strategic card games with a fantasy twist – Here to Slay
- Families or casual gamers who enjoy a mix of strategy and humor – Unstable Unicorns: Classic Edition
Not for
- Groups that prefer cooperative games or games with no direct conflict
- Players who dislike adult humor or are under 21 – Unstable Unicorns NSFW
